Hello Reloaders
I have been reloading since 1965. I have been using a balance beam scale. Just recently, my son suggested that I purchase a digital powder measure. (What does he know?) More recently, I am beginning to realize that he may know more than I give him credit for. So I have checked Midway for these machines, and I found three that I am interested in:
RCBS Charge master pro
RCBS charge master supreme
Lyman Gen 6
Hornady Auto charge pro
Does any one out there have preferences concerning these? How about use information?
I appreciate your comments.
Thanks
Bruce Baldwin
brubal@earthlink.net
Welcome to THL, Bruce. Nice to see new blood that actually posts!
I have used digital scales for reloading for over 20 years. I like 'em, but I'm not "married" to them. I DO NOT have any experience with any of the ones you mention. I use "generic" ones, not specifically designed for reloading. If I remember correctly, sakorick had the Hornady scale, and DavidLT has one that I can't remember the manufacturer of. J0e_bl0ggs also uses one, but I don't think it's one of the ones you are considering.
Give this thread a day or two to reach people, and then if you don't get any other responses, ping those folks I mentioned. If you need answers quicker than that, ping them today. I'm quite certain they, and everyone else at THL would be happy to discuss the subject with you.
Paul
Hello Bruce! I do not use a digital scale, I still use my RCBS balance beam scale. I have looked into the digital scales, thinking I might be able to make that part of the process "faster", but I don't think it is. I watched a video on one of the scales you mention and it was a 2-3 minute process for the scale to get back to zero and pour the specified amount of powder, so I opted not to get it.
I do remember sakorick purchasing one, he will probably have something for ya!! Also, if you do get one, would love to hear what you think about it.
Thanks for chiming in, David. Obviously, I thought you used one.
My experience is that using a digital scale does NOT speed up the process of reloading. Personally, I have no interest in speeding that process up, so that's not why I use one. My professional training and personal OCD simply prefer the unnecessary precision.
Paul
I have the RCBS Chargemaster 1500 and I love it. I bought the Hornady first and it quit working after throwing 12 charges. Not 12 every time, 12 total. So I returned it and got the RCBS and never looked back. At first I compared several charges between it and my balance scales but found they were all right there.
Quotepersonal OCD simply prefer the unnecessary precision.
Basically another reason I cannot pull the trigger. I would have to weigh out each charge on my other scale.
I use both. First the digital than confirm with the balance beam. They are rarely the exact same. Welcome to THL.
Bruce, don't have any hands on experience - only 'looking at' re the type you asked about. My go-to is still a balance (304 style) and when the ocd kicks in a check with the analytical balance, I'm in the volumetric camp so in general its all about powder thrower setup. Personally would not part with that much wedge for a plastic machine! All the best.
Hello THL'ers
Thanks so much for your replys. I am interested in accuracy and precision first then speed. I am leaning toward the RCBS, but only because RCBS did me a great favor when I was first reloading and I have not forgotten it. I'll post my final decision.
Stay safe
Bruce Baldwin
I finally did it. I purchased the RCBS Charge Master didgital powder measure for the reasons noted above. I reasoned that if it really turns out to be a lemon, i could get better results by complaining directly to RCBS than going through Midway.
I'll post the resullts.
Reasonable logic, for my two-cents-worth. Please let us know how it works for you.
Paul
OK! this is my last message in this thread. I have used my RCBS Charge Master digital powder measure. I find that it works just fine. I did have a problem with the instructions, but a call to RCBS cleared ut up nicely. I loaded some M! brass with 47.0 grains of 4064. The measudre worked just fine after wiping it down with some anti-static spray. I did find that I didn't need the blue tooth app. I paid extra for it which was a mistake. Am I happy? Generally yes.
Good report. That's pretty much what THL is about; honest evaluations of hunting related issues. Thanks!
Good to hear you're happy with the purchase.
Paul
Quote from: sakorick on August 03, 2022, 02:33:05 PMI use both. First the digital than confirm with the balance beam. They are rarely the exact same. Welcome to THL.
I don't trust anything if can't understand how it works. I will stay with my balance beam, it works perfectly.
Quote from: codger on November 26, 2023, 12:22:36 PMQuote from: sakorick on August 03, 2022, 02:33:05 PMI use both. First the digital than confirm with the balance beam. They are rarely the exact same. Welcome to THL.
I don't trust anything if can't understand how it works. I will stay with my balance beam, it works perfectly.
Us old "Codgers" tend to be like that.
Even if we go by other monikers!